Is Realpolitik Fundamentally Incompatible with Relational Ethics?
The tension between realpolitik and relational ethics appears, at first glance, irreconcilable. Realpolitik prioritizes power, survival, and strategic advantage in an anarchic international system. Relational ethics—such as those articulated through Ubuntu—prioritize mutual dignity, interdependence, and accountability. One framework is often described as pragmatic and unsentimental; the other as moral and communitarian. Yet the question requires analytical precision. Are these paradigms structurally incompatible? Or do they operate at different levels of statecraft, capable of partial integration under certain conditions? To answer this, we must first clarify the philosophical foundations of each. 1. The Core Logic of Realpolitik Realpolitik emerged from European statecraft traditions, often associated with figures like Otto von Bismarck and later theorized by thinkers such as Hans Morgenthau . It rests on several premises: The international system is anarchic (no central auth...